BMS before heat pumps
Heat is the hard part of decarbonising buildings. In hospitals, schools, universities and civic buildings, most of the direct emissions still come from boilers, and the answer most estates are working towards is electrification - usually heat pumps. But a heat pump is only as good as the system it is connected to, and the system is run by the BMS.
The case this article makes is simple: get the controls right first. A building that heats only when needed, at the lowest flow temperature that keeps people comfortable, with plant sequenced properly, needs a smaller heat pump, runs it more efficiently and gets more from every pound of capital. And once the heat pumps are in, they need controls service more than the boilers ever did.
What the BMS changes before any plant does
Three things decide how well a heat pump will work in an existing building, and the BMS controls all three:
- When heat is needed. Schedules, optimum start, holiday calendars and zoning set the hours the system runs. Every hour of unnecessary heating is load a heat pump would have to meet.
- How hot the water has to be. Heat pumps are far more efficient at lower flow temperatures. Weather compensation that actually works, return temperatures that come back cool, and emitters that are not starved by passing valves all bring the flow temperature down.
- How plant is sequenced. Boilers short-cycling, pumps running flat out against closed valves, bypasses open and mixing circuits fighting each other all raise return temperatures and waste energy - and in a hybrid system they decide whether the heat pump or the boiler does the work.
Approved Document L for England (2021 edition) expects new and replacement wet heating systems to be designed around a maximum flow temperature of 55°C where that can be done (GOV.UK Approved Document L). Many existing buildings were designed around 80°C or more. Finding out what flow temperature the building really needs - by trending it through a winter, lowering the compensation curve step by step and watching comfort and return temperatures - is controls work, and it tells the designer far more than a calculation alone.
The evidence from hospitals
NHS England has to cut direct emissions by 80% by 2032 and reach net zero by 2040, and reports itself on track (NHS England). Heat is where most of the remaining work sits - the NHS estate in England used about 11.3 billion kWh of energy in 2024/25 (HEFMA) - and BMS work keeps appearing in the published results.
- At Nottingham City Hospital, the contractor reported that the sitewide BMS upgrade alone saved about 7.48 GWh of gas a year - nearly five times its guaranteed target - as part of a much larger decarbonisation programme (contractor press release). That is a contractor-reported figure, not independently verified.
- South Warwickshire NHS Trust used a £243,613 public sector decarbonisation grant to expand its BMS, with projected savings of £70,143 a year and 268 tCO2e (Salix) - a projection, not a measured result.
Neither figure is a prediction for another site. Together they support the order of work: controls first, so the capital project starts from a building that already runs well. In a hospital, any change touching critical ventilation or water temperatures also needs the relevant safety group - see Which HTM governs which BMS point.
The heat pumps already installed are a service market
The Public Sector Decarbonisation Scheme has funded heat pumps in schools, hospitals, councils and universities since 2021. Phase 4 closed to new applications in November 2024 and is delivering projects to 2028 (GOV.UK). That leaves a large and growing installed base of low-carbon plant in public buildings - much of it integrated with an existing BMS, some of it not integrated at all.
Heat pumps are less forgiving than the boilers they replaced. Common problems an integrator can find and fix include:
- Flow temperatures set too high because the compensation curve was copied from the old boilers.
- Boilers doing the work in hybrid systems, because the changeover logic favours them or the heat pump keeps tripping on low flow.
- Short cycling from oversized units, poor buffer control or flow temperature setpoints with no deadband.
- Defrost and low-flow faults that nobody sees because the heat pump's own controller is not linked to the BMS alarms.
- Hot water strategy fighting the legionella controls, with immersion heaters quietly doing the pasteurisation.
None of these needs new capital. All of them need someone who understands both the heat pump and the system around it, with trend data to prove the fix. Seasonal changeover covers the autumn checks that catch many of them.
Commission the heat pump into the BMS properly
Many heat pump installations arrive with their own controller and a single enable signal from the BMS. That can work, but only if the integration is thought through. The BMS should see the heat pump's running state, flow and return temperatures, faults and defrost cycles, and the meters that show its electricity use and heat output - otherwise nobody can tell whether it is performing. Changeover between heat pump and boiler in a hybrid system needs clear, documented logic that the engineer, the estates team and the designer all agree on. And the handover should include a winter of trends, reviewed, rather than a sign-off on a mild day. The UK post-occupancy evidence on controls not being commissioned properly before handover applies here with extra force.
Carbon reporting changes too
Electrification changes how savings look on paper. The UK government's 2026 conversion factors put grid electricity at about 0.131 kgCO2e per kWh, down from 0.177 in the 2025 set - a fall of about a quarter. Gas factors reflect the fuel burned and change little from year to year. So a kWh of electricity saved now counts for less carbon than it did a year ago, while every kWh of gas displaced by a heat pump counts for relatively more.
| Grid electricity, kgCO2e per kWh (generation) | |
|---|---|
| 2025 factors | 0.17700 |
| 2026 factors | 0.13096 (-26%) |
| Carbon counted for 100,000 kWh of electricity saved | |
| 2025 factors | 17.7 tCO2e |
| 2026 factors | 13.1 tCO2e |
The same kWh saving counts for about a quarter less carbon - say which factor year a report uses.
For an integrator, the practical point is to state the factor year in every report, and to explain to the client why this year's carbon figure for an electrical saving is smaller than last year's.
Where funding stands
The big capital grant rounds have largely closed to new bids, which favours work that can be funded from revenue budgets. Optimisation, recommissioning and controls service fit that well: modest cost, quick results, measurable with existing meters, and a better starting point for whatever capital project comes next. Public buyers increasingly ask for a Carbon Reduction Plan and evidence of results, so a measured before-and-after from the controls work also helps the next funding application.
A sensible order of work
1. Measure the building as it runs. A winter of trend data on flow and return temperatures, plant run hours and space temperatures. 2. Fix the controls. Schedules, calendars, compensation curves, sequencing, passing valves and sensor faults. 3. Find the real flow temperature. Lower it in steps and watch comfort and returns. 4. Size and specify from that evidence, not from the original design. 5. Integrate and service the heat pump as part of the BMS - alarms, trends, changeover logic and seasonal checks.
What the studies really say covers the savings evidence, Where BMS tuning saves energy the measures, and Proving savings how to measure them. For estates with theatres, see Theatre ventilation setback under NETB 2026/1.
Related tools and training: the weather compensation savings, degree-day normalisation, CUSUM and heat recovery tools are in tecTools, and the LTHW system commissioning and Seasonal commissioning and changeover courses are in tecTraining.
Sources mentioned: NHS England net zero progress report (2025); Nottingham City Hospital decarbonisation, contractor press release (2026, contractor-reported); Salix case study, South Warwickshire NHS Trust (projected); GOV.UK PSDS Phase 4; Approved Document L (2021 edition); DESNZ greenhouse gas conversion factors 2026 (check against the DESNZ workbook). Savings depend on the building and how it is run.