Where BMS tuning saves energy - setpoints, schedules, VSDs and hysteresis
Most buildings do not need new plant to use less energy. They need the controls they already have to be set up the way the design intended, and then kept that way. Over the years overrides pile up, schedules drift and setpoints get nudged. This article walks through the places an integrator can usually find savings, and how to prove them afterwards.
Start with the data
Before changing anything, find out where the energy goes. Look at the main meters and any sub-meters, and pull trends for the plant you suspect: run hours, valve positions, supply temperatures, fan and pump speeds. A week of trends will often show more than a day of walking round. Record a baseline - you will need it to show what your changes achieved.
Schedules - the simplest saving
Plant that runs when nobody is in the building is the easiest waste to remove.
- Match the schedules to how the building is really used, including holidays and any areas with different hours.
- Use optimum start and stop where the controls support it, so plant comes on only as early as it needs to for the space to be ready.
- Replace permanent overrides with timed ones. A "run" override set for an evening event and never cleared can keep plant running for months.
- Check the night and weekend modes actually do what they say - frost protection only, not full occupied running.
Setpoints and deadbands
Small setpoint changes add up across a whole building.
- Keep a deadband between heating and cooling so the two are never on at once in the same space. Simultaneous heating and cooling is one of the most common and costly faults in commercial buildings.
- Agree a sensible comfort range with the client rather than a single fixed temperature, and set back outside occupied hours.
- Reset supply temperatures with demand. Weather-compensated heating flow temperatures and supply air temperature reset mean the plant does only as much as the building needs.
- Limit what users can change. Room adjusters with a narrow range keep people comfortable without letting a space drift a long way from setpoint.
Variable speed drives
Fans and pumps on variable speed drives offer some of the largest savings - when they are controlled properly. The fan and pump affinity laws say that, in theory, power varies roughly with the cube of speed, so running at 80 % speed needs only around half the power. Real systems save less than the theory, but the direction is clear.
- Control on the right signal. Pumps controlled from a differential pressure sensor near the index circuit, and fans from duct static pressure, use far less energy than a fixed speed.
- Reset the pressure setpoint with demand - trimming it down while every valve or damper is part open, and raising it only when one is nearly fully open.
- Look for drives left in hand at 50 Hz. It happens more often than you would think, usually after a fault or a test.
- Respect minimum speeds set by the plant manufacturer for cooling and lubrication.
Hysteresis and short-cycling
Plant that switches on and off rapidly wastes energy and wears out quickly. Boilers, chillers, compressors and staged heaters all suffer from it.
- Add hysteresis to on/off decisions, so a stage switches on at one value and off at another rather than chattering around a single point.
- Use minimum on and off times where the plant needs them - many manufacturers specify them.
- Stage plant on demand, bringing on additional boilers, chillers or pumps only when the running units cannot keep up.
- Rotate duty by run hours, so wear is shared and a standby unit is not left idle until the day it is needed.
Control loops that hunt
A control loop that oscillates - a valve swinging open and closed, a temperature that never settles - wastes energy and often makes people uncomfortable too. Trend the loop, then make small, careful tuning changes. Often the cause is not the tuning at all but an oversized valve, a sensor in the wrong place or a balancing problem, so look at the whole system before blaming the controller.
Free cooling and demand-controlled ventilation
Where the plant allows it, use outside air for cooling when conditions are right, and vary ventilation with occupancy - for example with CO2 sensors in meeting rooms and large open spaces - rather than running at design airflow all day. Both need sensors that are calibrated and in sensible places.
Sensors you can trust
Every saving above depends on accurate sensors. A temperature sensor reading two degrees low can keep heating running for hours longer than it should. Check key sensors against a calibrated reference, and recalibrate or replace any that have drifted.
Proving the savings
Compare energy use after the changes with your baseline, adjusting for the weather - degree days are the usual way to do this for heating and cooling. For larger projects, recognised measurement and verification approaches set out how to make the comparison robust. Share the results with the client: savings that are shown are savings that get kept.
Further reading
CIBSE Guide F (energy efficiency in buildings) and CIBSE Guide H (building control systems) cover these topics in depth, and are widely used in the UK.
Standard building blocks help keep strategies consistent: tecLogic includes HVAC modules for drives, hysteresis, run hours and setpoints, and a sequence stager with run-hours duty rotation. For quick calculations on site, tecTools has energy savings and project payback calculators.