Seasonal changeover - getting a building from heating to cooling, and back
Twice a year, almost every building with a BMS has to change its mind. In spring it stops being a heating building and becomes a cooling building; in autumn it goes back again. The controls strategy usually handles this automatically, but only if the settings, interlocks and plant behind it are still right. Changeover is where faults that hid all season show themselves, and where a short, well-timed visit pays off.
This guide is for systems integrators and controls engineers planning spring and autumn visits on existing buildings. It describes common practice and the published guidance behind it. Your client's strategy, maintenance standard and plant manufacturers' instructions always come first.
What actually changes at changeover
On paper the change is simple: heating demand falls and cooling demand rises, or the other way round. In the BMS, a surprising number of things move with it:
- Enable and lockout logic - the outside air temperatures, dates or demand signals that allow boilers, heat pumps and chillers to run.
- Setpoints and deadbands - space setpoints, any seasonal offsets and the gap between heating and cooling.
- Reset schedules - weather compensation on heating, chilled water and supply air resets on cooling.
- Free cooling and economiser logic - mixing dampers, free cooling coils and night purge.
- Optimum start and stop - which has to relearn how long the building takes to reach temperature in the new season.
- Humidity control - humidifiers in winter, dehumidification in summer, where the building has them.
- Plant rotation and standby - duty and standby changes, and plant that has sat idle for months.
Every one of these is a chance for the building to start the season in the wrong state. The most common changeover complaint - "it is too hot" in a warm April week, or "the heating is not on" on the first cold morning in October - nearly always traces back to one of them.
The spring checklist
Spring changeover is about proving cooling before the building needs it. The aim is to finish before the first warm week, not during it.
- Cooling enable and heating lockout. Check the conditions that let cooling run and stop heating. Look at the actual values in the strategy, not the description in the O&M manual - they are often different after years of tweaks.
- Chillers and heat rejection. Confirm the chillers, dry coolers or condensers start, stage and rotate as the sequence says. Plant that has not run since autumn deserves a proper start under the manufacturer's procedure, by whoever is responsible for it.
- Chilled water reset. If the strategy resets chilled water temperature from load or outside air, check the reset is active and the limits are sensible. A reset left fixed at its coldest value is easy to miss.
- Free cooling and economisers. Prove dampers and free cooling coils move to the right positions, and that the logic is in its summer state. Winter limits left in place can stop free cooling altogether.
- Humidity. Check humidifiers are disabled or reset for summer, and that any dehumidification logic is enabled where it is part of the design.
- Solar gain zones. South and west facing zones, glazed atria and top floors overheat first. Check their sensors, setpoints and any blind control before the sun gets high.
- Deadband. Look at the gap between heating and cooling setpoints in zones and at the central plant. Too narrow a gap is the classic cause of heating and cooling running at the same time.
The autumn checklist
Autumn readiness is about protecting the plant and the building before the first frost, and getting the heating to behave from the first cold morning.
- Frost protection. Check frost thermostats, frost protection setpoints and the sequence that runs pumps and opens valves when it is cold. Prove it actually acts - a frost routine that has never been tested is an assumption.
- Heat source sequencing. Confirm boilers or heat pumps start, stage and rotate as designed, and that lead and lag changes happen.
- Weather compensation. Look at the compensation curve against last winter's trends. If rooms ran too warm on mild days or too cold on cold days, the curve may need adjusting. Many curves have not been looked at since handover.
- Optimum start. Check the learning or adaptive settings. Some controllers need a few days of heating weather to relearn, so expect early-season preheat times to move.
- Pump exercise. Pumps that have sat all summer should have been exercised by the BMS. Check the routine is enabled and that it ran.
- Heating lockout and summer overrides. Clear anything left in hand over the summer - cooling forced on, heating forced off - and check the heating lockout releases at the right condition.
The mixed-mode weeks
The hardest part of changeover is not the day you switch, but the weeks either side. In spring and autumn, a building can need heating in the morning and cooling by mid-afternoon, and different facades can need opposite things at the same time.
This is when heating and cooling fight. The usual causes are:
- deadbands too narrow at zone or plant level;
- heating and cooling lockouts that overlap, so both central plants are enabled;
- zone controllers using different setpoints from the central plant strategy;
- reheat on air systems working against a supply air temperature that is colder than it needs to be.
There is no single right deadband. Rules of thumb from controls suppliers vary, and published checklists from different countries suggest different figures. The right value depends on the building's use, the people in it and what the lease or service agreement says about temperatures. Agree it with the client and record it, rather than applying one number everywhere.
Trends to watch in the first fortnight
Changeover is a good time to set up a short list of trends and look at them a week or two later. Useful ones include:
- space temperatures against setpoints, especially on the facades that change first;
- flow and return temperatures on heating and chilled water;
- valve positions on heating and cooling coils in the same air handling unit or zone - both open at once is the signature of simultaneous heating and cooling;
- plant run hours and starts - short-cycling boilers or chillers show up quickly;
- chilled water delta-T - a low delta-T often means valves passing or coils bypassing;
- optimum start times - how early the plant starts, and whether it is still settling.
Compare with last season's trends if you have them. Last year's data is often the best baseline you will get.
Common faults, year after year
Practice and the trade press report the same handful of changeover faults again and again:
- economiser or free cooling logic left in its winter state;
- heating and cooling lockouts set wrongly or overlapping;
- deadbands too narrow, so heating and cooling run together;
- weather compensation curves never revisited;
- frost protection and pump exercise routines not checked before winter;
- chiller or condenser sequences not proven before the first hot spell;
- humidifier and dehumidification setpoints carried over between seasons.
None of these needs new equipment to fix. Most need someone to look at the right point at the right time of year.
Recording it
End each changeover visit with a short record: what was checked, what was changed (with before and after values), what is still outstanding, and what to look at next season. Keep the trends you set up. This record is what turns a changeover from a yearly scramble into a routine - and it is evidence for the client of work they would otherwise never see.
Where this fits
Seasonal commissioning is a recognised part of new building handover - BREEAM credits look for it within the first year of occupation, and the BSRIA Soft Landings framework (BG 54) builds aftercare and fine-tuning into the first years after handover. Beyond that, nothing in regulation requires it, but buildings keep changing, and the same checks keep finding the same drift.
For the wider service year, see The BMS service visit that pays for itself. The original commissioning sequence these checks build on is in Commissioning a BMS, and the energy side of setpoints, schedules and deadbands is covered in Where BMS tuning saves energy. To find what the trends are telling you, Fault detection on a BMS sets out the classic rules.
Related tools and training: the weather compensation savings, out-of-hours running cost and degree-day calculators are in tecTools, and the LTHW and CHW system commissioning courses are in tecTraining.
Published guidance mentioned: BREEAM seasonal commissioning (BRE); BSRIA BG 54/2018 Soft Landings Framework. These describe the process in their own terms - follow your project's specification and the manufacturers' instructions for any plant you work on.