Commissioning a BMS - a practical sequence and the faults to look for
Commissioning is where a controls installation proves it does what the design said it would. Done in the right order it is calm and predictable; done out of order it turns into days of chasing faults that were really someone else's unfinished work. This article sets out a sequence many integrators follow, the checks at each stage, and the faults that come up again and again. Your project specification and commissioning plan always come first - treat this as a checklist to compare against, not a replacement for them.
Before you start
Most commissioning delays are caused before the controls engineer arrives. It is worth confirming a few things in writing before booking days on site:
- The mechanical and electrical installation is complete for the systems you are commissioning - plant installed, pipework filled and flushed, ductwork sealed, power available to the panels.
- The design intent is clear. You need the control strategy or description of operation, the points list and I/O schedule, and current wiring and panel drawings. If the strategy is missing or vague, raise it now rather than guessing on site.
- Water and air balancing is planned. Control loops cannot be tuned properly on a system that has not been balanced, so agree the order with the commissioning specialist.
- Someone owns the commissioning plan - who witnesses what, when, and what "done" looks like for each system.
Stage 1 - panels and power
Start with the panels de-energised. Check the panel against its drawings, labelling and terminations, then the supplies once it is safe to power up: control transformers, 24 V AC and DC rails, fusing and earthing. Electrical testing must follow your company's safe systems of work and be carried out by people competent to do it. Note any damage or missing items before you go further - it saves arguments later.
Stage 2 - point-to-point checks
Every input and output is proved from the field device back to the controller and on to the head end. This is the stage that is most often rushed and the one that causes the most trouble when it is.
- Sensors: check the reading against a calibrated reference, confirm the range and scaling in the controller, and record any offset you apply.
- Analogue outputs: drive each valve and damper actuator through its full stroke and confirm 0 % and 100 % are the right way round and match the drawings.
- Digital inputs and outputs: prove run, fault and status signals from the plant itself, not just a link in the panel. Check that commands start the right item of plant.
- Fail-safe positions: confirm what each actuator does on loss of signal and loss of power, and that it matches the strategy - frost and fire positions especially.
Record every point as you go. A point-to-point sheet signed off point by point is far easier to defend than a ticked box at the end.
Stage 3 - networks and integration
Once the local I/O is proved, bring up the networks. Check controller addressing, device instances and network numbers, baud rates and terminations on serial buses, and IP settings on Ethernet. For third-party plant - chillers, boilers, meters, variable speed drives - confirm the points you read and write against the manufacturer's documentation, including units, scaling and which values are writable. Then pull a cable or power down a device and make sure a communications-loss alarm actually appears.
Stage 4 - control loops and sequences
With the points and networks proved, test the logic against the strategy, one system at a time.
- Run each sequence through every mode - occupied, unoccupied, optimum start, frost protection, fault and fire - and watch the plant respond, not just the graphic.
- Tune control loops with small step changes and trend the result. A loop that hunts wastes energy and wears actuators; one that is too slow never reaches setpoint.
- Prove safety and interlock functions by simulating the real condition where it is safe to do so, and record the result.
- Check duty and standby changeover, run-hour rotation and plant restart after a power failure.
Stage 5 - alarms, trends, schedules and graphics
Operators judge a BMS by what they see, so this stage matters more than it looks. Check that every alarm has a sensible priority, text an operator understands and a route to the right person. Set up trends that will help with the first season's fine-tuning. Load the agreed occupancy schedules and holidays. Walk through the graphics against the plant and make sure values, units and commands are all live and in the right place.
Stage 6 - witnessing and handover
Demonstrate the systems to the client or their representative against the commissioning plan, and keep the signed records. Handover usually includes as-built drawings and points lists, the final strategy, backups of every controller and the head end, user accounts with sensible permissions, and operator training. Plan a return visit: many systems only show their faults in the first change of season, and seasonal commissioning is where a good job becomes a good building.
Faults that come up again and again
- Sensors wired correctly but scaled wrongly in the controller, so readings are plausible but wrong.
- Actuators reversed - the valve opens when the controller asks it to close.
- Plant "proved" from a panel link rather than the plant itself, hiding a missing run signal.
- Duplicate addresses or device instances on a network, causing intermittent communications.
- Third-party integration points mapped to the wrong register or with the wrong word order.
- Overrides left in place after testing, so a system runs in hand for months.
- Alarms that flood the operator on day one because nobody set priorities or delays.
Further reading
Published guidance covers this in far more depth. In the UK, the CIBSE Commissioning Codes - in particular Code C for automatic controls and Code M for commissioning management - and BSRIA's commissioning guides are widely referenced in specifications, and Part L of the Building Regulations expects fixed building services to be commissioned and the results notified. Check which documents and editions your specification names, and use those.
If you are building up your own commissioning knowledge, our tecTraining courses include commissioning good practice with a quiz and certificate, and tecTools has commissioning sheets and I/O schedules you can fill in on site.