The BMS health check - how to survey an existing system in a day

A BMS health check is a one-off, fixed-price survey of an existing system. It looks at the whole installation - head end, network, controllers, field devices, strategy and records - scores each area and ends with a prioritised list of what to do. For a client it is a low-risk way to find out where they stand. For an integrator it is often the natural first step with a new client and the starting point for a service contract.

This guide sets out a structure many integrators use for a one-day survey. It is a framework to adapt, not a standard: the size of the building, the age of the system and what the client wants from the result will all change the detail.

Before you go: documents and access

A day on site goes much further when the preparation has been done. Ask for these in advance:

Agree access in writing: which plant rooms and risers, who holds keys, who can give you head end and remote access credentials, and whether you may change anything on the day or only observe. On a live building, agree that the survey is look-and-record unless the client asks otherwise, and follow the site's permit and safe working rules for any plant you touch.

The scorecard areas

A good health check looks across the whole system, not only at what is easy to see from the head end. The areas below are common ground across published BMS maintenance guidance and practice:

Scoring and priorities

Keep the scoring simple enough that a client understands it at a glance. A common approach is a 0 to 3 score per area:

Weight the areas to suit the client. For a hospital or data hall, recoverability and alarms might matter more than anything; for an office landlord, energy and schedules might lead. Say clearly how you weighted them.

Then pull out the findings into a short register, each with a priority. Many integrators use three or four levels - for example, safety or compliance first, then risk of failure, then energy and comfort, then housekeeping. The point of the score is to start a conversation; the register is what the client acts on.

Cyber hygiene basics

A BMS is now a networked IT system, and it is increasingly the first thing a client's IT or security team asks about. A health check should at least record:

You are recording the position, not carrying out a penetration test. The UK National Cyber Security Centre publishes free guidance on securing operational technology and connected systems, and pointing the client to it, and to their own IT team, is often the right recommendation. BMS cyber hygiene evidence sets out a fuller evidence pack.

Mapping to BACS classes

One of the most useful frames for the result is the set of building automation and control (BACS) efficiency classes in BS EN ISO 52120-1:2022. The standard groups control functions - heating, cooling, ventilation, lighting, blinds and technical building management - and rates them in four classes, from D, the least efficient, up to A, the most. It replaced BS EN 15232-1:2017.

A health check can give an indicative view of where a building sits, and what moving up a class would involve. It must be presented as exactly that: an indicative self-assessment, not a certified rating against the standard. Even so, "your building is broadly at class C for heating control - here is what class B would take" gives the client a standards-backed reason for a proposal rather than a sales pitch.

There is also a regulatory link worth knowing. Approved Document L Volume 2 (England) includes provisions for building automation and control systems where a building's heating or air conditioning output exceeds 180 kW - both for new buildings and where a system is installed or replaced in an existing one - and notes that a class A system under BS EN ISO 52120-1 meets the specification it describes. Check which edition applies to the work in question, and remember that Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own documents.

Presenting the result

The report is what the client keeps, so make it easy to read and easy to forward:

Keep savings estimates honest. Say how they were worked out and what they depend on, and avoid presenting them as guaranteed. Published studies, mostly from North America, have found a wide range of results - a US national laboratory study of BMS trend data from 151 buildings (PNNL, 2021) found operational problems in almost every building, with savings potential ranging from zero to 50%. Your survey is a starting point for measuring the real effect on this building.

What the large studies measured - and the modelled ceiling - Whole-building energy savings, % (medians)
Recommissioning existing buildings - 446 projects (measured)6.4% (IQR 3.4-12.4%)
Fault detection and diagnostics (FDD) - after two years (measured)9%
Potential found in BMS trend data - 151 buildings (potential)12%
Optimised controls across the whole stock (modelled)29%

Medians, not promises - individual results ran from close to zero to over 50%.

What the large North American studies measured - useful context for any estimate in a health check report. Source: Crowe et al. 2020 (LBNL); Smart Energy Analytics Campaign, cited in Crowe et al. 2023 (LBNL); Katipamula et al. 2021 (PNNL); Fernandez et al. 2017 (PNNL, DOE summary). Flags: North American, Top bar modelled.

Pricing a fixed-fee health check

Most integrators price health checks as a fixed fee, so the client knows the cost before they commit. Things that drive the price:

Some integrators credit the health check fee against a first-year service contract or the first improvement project. Whatever you choose, be clear about what is included, what is out of scope and how long the client will wait for the report.

Next steps

A health check works best as the start of a relationship rather than a one-off. The findings feed directly into a planned service programme - see The BMS service visit that pays for itself - and the larger items become costed projects. To make the result measurable, Proving savings covers baselines, degree days and CUSUM. For the strategy side, Where BMS tuning saves energy and Commissioning a BMS cover the controls themselves, and Alarm rationalisation deals with alarm load.

Related tools and training: the commissioning checklist, sensor scaling, energy savings and payback calculators are in tecTools, and the Energy and building control classes course in tecTraining explains the BACS classes in more depth.

Published guidance mentioned: BS EN ISO 52120-1:2022; CIBSE TM39 Building energy metering; Approved Document L Volume 2 (England); NCSC guidance on operational technology. These documents are described here in our own words - refer to the documents themselves for their requirements.

More articles from 3EC

3EC logo