Retail, hotels and warehouses - where the BMS still earns its keep
Retail, hotels and logistics are big users of energy, but they are awkward markets for a controls integrator. The largest single load in a supermarket is usually run by someone else's controller. A hotel's energy follows guests rather than a timetable. A warehouse may have a very simple BMS, or none, and a roof full of heaters. And almost every published savings figure in these sectors comes from a company selling the product.
So this article is about method. It covers where the energy goes in each building type, the controls levers that are well understood, and how to talk about savings when the independent evidence is thin. Where a figure comes from a vendor, it says so.
Where the energy goes
The UK benchmarks most people still use are in CIBSE TM46 (2008). They are old, and the CIBSE document is paid, so the figures below were read from a published copy of its table - check them against TM46 before relying on them in a report.
| Electricity | |
|---|---|
| General office | 95 |
| General retail | 165 |
| Retail warehouse | 70 |
| Storage warehouse or depot | 35 |
| Refrigerated warehouse | 145 |
| Fossil fuel (heating) | |
| General office | 120 |
| General retail | 0 |
| Retail warehouse | 170 |
| Storage warehouse or depot | 160 |
| Refrigerated warehouse | 80 |
TM46 dates from 2008. In a storage warehouse heating is most of the energy, which is why heating control, destratification and dock doors come first. Measured landlord benchmarks (REEB) are added once read from the published charts.
The pattern is the useful part. A general shop is almost all electricity. A storage warehouse is mostly heating: 160 of its 195 kWh per square metre in TM46 comes from fossil fuel. A refrigerated warehouse is mostly electricity again. The Better Buildings Partnership publishes more recent measured benchmarks for offices and shopping centres from landlord data each year (REEB benchmarks), which are worth reading directly for those building types.
Retail - the refrigeration boundary
In large UK retail chains, refrigeration is about 42% of electricity use, ranging from 29% in hypermarkets to 60% in small stores (International Journal of Refrigeration, 2023). It is usually controlled by a dedicated refrigeration controller, maintained by a refrigeration contractor with F-gas certification. That boundary matters, and the integrator should respect it.
What the BMS can do is everything around it:
- Monitor and alarm. Bring case and cold room temperatures, plant status and alarms into the BMS, with sensible alarm priorities, so problems are seen out of hours.
- Heat reclaim. Where refrigeration heat is recovered for store heating or hot water, make sure the BMS actually uses it before firing a boiler.
- HVAC against cold aisles. Open cases spill cold air. Heating that fights the cold aisle, or dehumidification set without regard to the cases, wastes energy on both sides.
- Night blinds and doors. An advocacy source suggests night blinds on open cases can save up to 20% of total energy, and doors on cabinets can cut the refrigeration capacity needed by up to 40% (EIA report) - advocacy figures, so treat them as indicative.
The F-gas rules phase HFC use down by 79% by 2030, so some refrigerants will become scarcer and dearer (SEPA / Environment Agency leaflet). Leak monitoring through the BMS is a natural addition, but work on the refrigeration circuit itself stays with certified refrigeration engineers.
Hotels - follow the guests
No independent published figure for HVAC's share of hotel energy was found. The large North American recommissioning dataset found its lowest median saving in lodging - about 3% - which is a useful reminder that hotels are not an easy win (Crowe et al. 2020).
The method is clear even where the numbers are not:
- Unsold rooms. Rooms that are not let tonight should not be held at guest setpoint. Linking the property management system's room status to the room controls lets unsold rooms sit in a deep setback and come back before check-in.
- Occupied but empty rooms. Occupancy sensing or key-card switching lets an occupied room relax when the guest is out. No independent UK case was found to put a figure on the saving, so measure it on site.
- Back of house and public areas. Kitchens, laundries, function rooms and lobbies have their own timetables - schedules matched to events, not to a fixed day, are where the out-of-hours running hides.
Warehouses - heat, height and doors
In a heated warehouse, heating is most of the bill, and three things decide how much is wasted.
- Stratification. Warm air rises. In a tall warehouse the roof can be several degrees warmer than the floor in winter, while the thermostat at working height calls for more heat. Destratification fans push the warm air back down. No independent figure for the saving was found - test it on site rather than forecast it.
- Dock doors. Doors left open, and unsealed dock leveller pits in chilled sites, let heat or cold escape. One door maker estimated 589,000 kWh a year saved at a chilled distribution centre from dock measures (door maker case study) - a vendor estimate. Interlocks that stop heaters running while doors are open, and alarms on doors left open, are simple controls measures.
- Heater control. Radiant and warm-air heaters with their own local controls, often with no time schedule, no frost-only mode and sensors in the wrong place. Bringing them under one schedule with sensors at working height is often the first step.
Talking about savings in these sectors
The honest position is that independent UK measured evidence for retail, hotel and warehouse controls optimisation is thin, and most published percentages come from vendors. That is not a reason to avoid the work. It is a reason to sell it differently:
- quote published figures as published, with their source and whether they are measured, modelled or claimed;
- say that the building may sit above or below any published figure;
- measure before and after, adjusting for weather and trading pattern, and report the method.
Large retail, hotel and logistics groups will be preparing for ESOS Phase 4 through 2026 and 2027, and their audit reports will list controls recommendations - a ready-made starting point. ESOS Phase 4 and demand flexibility covers that route, and Proving savings covers the measurement.
Shaping the offer
A multi-site service for these sectors might include a schedule and out-of-hours review per site, refrigeration alarm integration (with the refrigeration contractor), unsold-room setback for hotels, destratification and dock door interlock checks for warehouses, and a portfolio report comparing sites against each other. Comparing a chain's own sites is often more persuasive than any benchmark.
Related tools and training: the carpet plot and load profile, out-of-hours running cost, degree-day normalisation and alarm load worksheet tools are in tecTools, and the Servicing and optimising an existing BMS course is in tecTraining.
Sources mentioned: CIBSE TM46 (2008, figures read from a published copy of its table); Better Buildings Partnership REEB benchmarks; International Journal of Refrigeration (2023); EIA report on supermarket refrigeration (advocacy source); SEPA and Environment Agency F-gas leaflet; Crowe et al. 2020 (North American); a door maker's case study (vendor estimate). Results depend on the building, its use and its plant.