Widening the climate bands safely - Bizot for BMS engineers
For decades many museums, galleries and archives held their spaces at a tight, fixed condition - roughly 20°C and 50% relative humidity, within a few per cent either way, all year round. Holding that line takes a great deal of heating, cooling, humidifying and dehumidifying. The sector has moved on, and the BMS is where the change actually happens.
This article is for integrators who look after museums, galleries, archives and heritage collections. It covers what the guidance now says, how to prove a space is stable enough to widen its band, the control faults that waste the most energy, and why the conservator always has the final word.
What changed
The Bizot Group's Green Protocol, renewed in 2023, recommends stable conditions within a wider band for most collections: 16-25°C and 40-60% relative humidity, with limits on how fast conditions may fluctuate (NEMO summary; Bizot Green Protocol 2023). The fluctuation wording should be read in the protocol itself before a client's specification is written.
The accompanying Bizot Handbook 1 (2023) explains the reasoning: the old strict limits came from conservative experiments, relaxing them gives a considerable energy reduction, and no studies show that moderate mid-range humidity variation increases insect risk (Bizot Handbook 1). The original protocol dates from 2015, and several large UK national museums are listed as applying the guidelines.
Some materials and some loans still need tighter conditions, and Historic England publishes its own environmental management performance standards for its sites (Historic England). The wider band is a recommendation for most collections, not a rule for all of them.
What the savings evidence says - and does not
HVAC is often 60-70% of a museum building's energy, according to the Gallery Climate Coalition, which also suggests minor temperature and humidity adjustments can save about 24-25% of energy cost - a campaign estimate rather than a measured result (Gallery Climate Coalition).
The clearest single example is a US art museum that trialled the revised ranges. One report gives about a 9.5% fall in energy use (The Art Newspaper); another gives a 30% reduction in energy cost at the same museum (Maine Public / NPR, republished by KUNC). The two are not contradictory so much as measuring different things - energy use and energy cost - and that is exactly why a figure should always carry its basis. No measured UK national museum figure for band widening was found.
| One US art museum - energy use, after trialling the wider ranges (energy use) | 9.5% |
|---|---|
| The same museum - energy cost, in another report (energy cost) | 30% |
| Minor temperature and humidity changes - campaign estimate (energy cost) | about 24-25% |
HVAC is often 60-70% of the energy a museum building uses. Energy use and energy cost are different measures - the two reports on one museum measure different things.
Step one - trend before touching anything
Widening a band starts with evidence about the space as it is, not with a setpoint change.
1. Check the sensors. Temperature and humidity sensors drift, and humidity sensors drift more. Compare each one with a calibrated reference before trusting a year of trends. 2. Trend every space for a full year if possible. Temperature, relative humidity and the plant states that drive them - heating, cooling, humidifier and dehumidifier outputs. 3. Look at stability, not just the average. How fast do conditions change in an hour and in a day? Which spaces swing when doors open, crowds arrive or the sun comes round? 4. Map the spaces to what they hold. Stores, permanent galleries, temporary exhibition spaces and loan galleries all need different treatment.
The trend data is what the conservator needs to make a decision. It also shows where the plant is working hardest for the least benefit.
Step two - stop the plant fighting itself
The biggest waste in a tightly controlled museum is often plant working against itself, and the BMS can see it:
- Heating and cooling at the same time. A cooling coil dehumidifying the air and a reheat coil warming it straight back up, or two zones on neighbouring units doing opposite jobs.
- Humidifying and dehumidifying at once. A humidifier adding moisture in one part of the system while a cooling coil removes it in another - often because two humidity sensors disagree.
- Deadbands too narrow. With a 1% humidity deadband, plant chases every small change. A wider deadband inside the agreed band lets conditions drift gently instead of being forced back.
Step three - widen gradually, with seasonal drift
Once the conservator agrees a new band, move to it in stages rather than all at once. A common approach is to let conditions drift slowly with the seasons - a little warmer and more humid in summer, cooler and drier in winter - within the band and within the agreed rate-of-change limits. That uses the building's own thermal and moisture mass and asks far less of the plant than holding one fixed point all year.
Write the strategy down in the controls description: the band for each space, the seasonal setpoint schedule, the deadbands, the rate-of-change limits and the alarms. Then trend the result and review it with the conservator after each season.
Loans and zoning
Lenders' loan agreements often still require tighter conditions than the Bizot band. Running the whole building to the strictest loan's condition wastes energy everywhere else. Where the plant allows it, zone the building so that only the loan galleries run tight, and the rest of the building sits in the wider band. Where it does not, that limitation is worth flagging in a capital plan.
Who signs off
The conservator or collections care lead decides what conditions the collection can tolerate. The integrator provides the evidence, implements the agreed strategy and proves it is being delivered. Never widen a band, change a deadband or relax an alarm in a collection space without that sign-off in writing - and keep the trend evidence, because the next loan request will ask for it.
Shaping the offer
A heritage service built on this might include a sensor calibration round, a year of structured trending with a stability report per space, a plant-fighting review, a staged band-widening plan agreed with the conservator, loan-gallery zoning advice and a seasonal review. Fault detection on a BMS covers rules that catch fighting plant automatically, and What the studies really say puts savings figures in context.
Related tools and training: the museum band checker (time inside the Bizot bands and the rate of change from a T/RH trend), the psychrometrics, carpet plot and load profile, and BMS health check tools are in tecTools, and the Trend diagnostics - charts that find the waste course is in tecTraining.
Sources mentioned: Bizot Green Protocol (2023) and Bizot Handbook 1 (2023), via the National Museum Directors' Council and NEMO; Gallery Climate Coalition (campaign estimate); The Art Newspaper and Maine Public / NPR (republished by KUNC) on one US art museum (North American; the two reports use different bases); Historic England environmental management performance standards. Conditions for any collection are the conservator's decision.